(from The Aims of Argument, p. 34)

Claim:

Qualifier?

Exceptions?

***************

Reason 1

What makes this reason relevant?

What makes this reason good?

What evidence supports this reason?

Reason 2

What makes this reason relevant?

What makes this reason good?

What evidence supports this reason?

Reason 3

What makes this reason relevant?

What makes this reason good?

What evidence supports this reason?

Reason 4

What makes this reason relevant?

What makes this reason good?

What evidence supports this reason?

***************************************************************

Objection:

Rebuttal:

Objection:

Rebuttal:

Objection:

Rebuttal:

Objection:

Rebuttal: