A Toulmin Model for Analyzing Arguments 
(modified from Timothy W. Crusius and Carolyn E. Channell, The Aims of Argument, p. 34)

Claim:

Qualifier?

Exceptions?

***************
Reason 1

What makes this reason relevant?

What makes this reason effective?

What evidence supports this reason?

Is this evidence sufficient?

Is this evidence credible?

Is this evidence accurate?

Reason 2

What makes this reason relevant?

What makes this reason effective?

What evidence supports this reason?

Is this evidence sufficient?

Is this evidence credible?

Is this evidence accurate?

Reason 3

What makes this reason relevant?

What makes this reason effective?

What evidence supports this reason?

Is this evidence sufficient?

Is this evidence credible?

Is this evidence accurate?

***************************************************************

Objection:

Rebuttal: 

Objection:

Rebuttal:

Objection:

Rebuttal: